WorldFootprints_logo

Connecting you to the world
one story at a time

Dark Tourism in Cambodia: Exploitation and Cultural Insensitivity

Over four years in the early 1970s, Cambodia, a Southeast Asian country now frequented by backpacking tourists, faced one of the worst human atrocities imaginable– a state-sponsored genocide wiping out one-third of the nation’s population.

Now, barely 40 years since the tragedies of the Cambodian genocide, which was carried out by the Khmer Rouge regime under the leadership of Pol Pot, Cambodia is riding the wave of tourists’ morbid curiosity in what some experts call the ultimate form of voyeurism– dark tourism. There are two schools of thought about this niche of the tourism industry. The first is that dark tourism can be used as a tool to educate visitors about global issues and the sad pasts countries have endured. Others argue that dark tourism merely is feeding trauma fetishes.

What is Dark Tourism?

Dark tourism is a niche within the travel industry that refers to travelers visiting places marked by mass tragedy, disaster, and death. This subset of tourism, which includes all things grim and somber, can be found around the world. From touring the Auschwitz concentration camp in Poland, swimming in an atomic lake created by nuclear fallout in Kazakhstan or simulating a terrifying border crossing from Mexico into the United States– dark tourism continues to increase in popularity. There is possibly no place that has benefited from dark tourism as much as Cambodia.

Globally, these popular tourist attractions bringing in millions of dollars. It’s obvious that generating that amount of money from tourism is appealing, especially in more impoverished places like Cambodia with low gross domestic products. However, understanding where the money from these dark tours goes and who is benefiting from them presents a major moral dilemma that revolves around tourist etiquette and historical education. It also leads to a bigger, more existential question: why are we as humans attracted to death and destruction?

Toul Sleng Genocide Museum S21, Phnom Phen. Photo: CreativeCommons
Toul Sleng Genocide Museum S21, Phnom Phen. Photo: CreativeCommons

Making dark tourism distinctions

Some places fall under the category of “dark tourism” because of their somber history, like Ground Zero in New York City, the Memorial of the Murdered Jews in Berlin, and the Choeung Ek Memorial in Phnom Penh.  These places serve as historical memorial sites but don’t cross the invisible line into murkier dark tourism territory.

On the opposite side of the metaphorical line lies a distinctly different type of dark tourism, one that offers tourists activities like playing Nazis versus Allies in a WWII reenactment, and shooting an assault rifle near the Cambodian Killing Fields. That’s right. Where firing squads once massacred groups of Cambodians, tourists can now pay big money to shoot an AK-47, most of which are from the Khmer Rouge era. Those who are willing to pay extra can shoot live targets– cows. The question is, why would tourists want to? To make matters worse, the profits from shooting these assault rifles goes back to the Cambodian government, straight into the pockets of the Army. This means the locals aren’t directly benefiting at all.

This is where the ethics of dark tourism come into play. While there are landmarks that stand as tribute to atrocities that have been overcome or are testaments to the human spirit enduring tragedy and persevering, there are tourist sites that are driven by voyeurism and attract people who get enjoyment from recreating the pain of others.

Choeung Ek is the site of a former orchard and mass grave of victims of the Khmer Rouge - killed between 1975 and 1979. Photo: Clay Gilliland
Choeung Ek is the site of a former orchard and mass grave of victims of the Khmer Rouge – killed between 1975 and 1979. Photo: Clay Gilliland

Historical Education or Feeding Fetishes?

While we may never know why humans are drawn to devastation, experts and psychologists speculate about what dark tourists’ intentions are and criticize why the market for it exists: what purpose is it serving as a form of travel?

Optimists believe that tourists partake in the dark attractions in Cambodia to educate themselves on the gruesome Cambodian genocide. Skeptics find dark tourism a way to fetishize trauma and tragedy. They make the argument that there is nothing educational about shooting an automatic weapon in a field only all too recently riddled by bullets, blood, and bodies.

Professor Lennon from Glasgow Caledonian University London helped coin the term “dark tourism” and has spent his career understanding the motivations for visits to haunted places. He believes that dark tourists are “motivated by a desire for actual or symbolic encounters with death.”

That could explain why tourists pay hundreds of dollars to shoot cows and pigs with the same guns that were once used to kill people under the Communist regime of Cambodia better than just that they simply have a twisted curiosity. Perhaps, the human psyche’s preoccupation with death is what motivates people to partake in dark tourist activities like killing live animals, but a fixation on the impermanence of life doesn’t justify insensitive actions.

Victims of the Khmer Rouge, Cheung Ek killing fields, near Pnomh Penh. Photo: Satbir Singh
Victims of the Khmer Rouge, Cheung Ek killing fields, near Pnomh Penh. Photo: Satbir Singh

Tourists Behaving Badly

In every destination, it’s easy to spot tourists behaving in a culturally inappropriate and insensitive way. But in Phom Phenh and some other dark tourism locations, this behavior is taken to an extreme. While visiting the mass graves in Cambodia, I’ve seen tourists taking shortcuts across the gravesites, despite clear signage forbidding it. Selfies are snapped with the thousands of skulls that line the Choeung Ek Memorial are all too common, as are photos of influencers posing somberly inside the S-21, a high-school complex that was converted into a prison and torture facility during the Cambodian Genocide.

Toul Sleng Genocide Museum is where people were tortured and mutilated before being shot on the Killing Fields. This structure was once a school. Photo: CreativeCommons
Toul Sleng Genocide Museum is where people were tortured and mutilated before being shot on the Killing Fields. This structure was once a school. Photo: CreativeCommons

Is Dark Tourism in Cambodia Necessary?

Dark tourism in places like Phomn Phenh may bring awareness to social and political issues that might otherwise go unrecognized by visitors. However, the argument that these places educate tourists only holds up when certain codes of visitor conduct are upheld and historically grim sites are respected by visiting tourists.

While there are lots of opinions on dark tourism, ultimately, the verdict as to its appropriateness should lie with the people of Cambodia. The questions that every traveler visiting these tragic landmarks should be asking are, ‘how are the ones most affected by these traumas affected by this kind of tourism?’ and ‘are these attractions providing educational insight for tourists from the perspective of the locals and the survivors.

Prayer beads in Choeung Ek - the Killing Fields
Prayer beads in Choeung Ek – the Killing Fields

 


go___________

Aerial view of Niagara Falls with a Maiden of the Mist boat.

Exploring Niagara Falls

Niagara Falls, one of America’s most scenic wonders, wasn’t always a pristine park open to the public. Comprised of three waterfalls that straddle the U.S.-Canadian border, the falls have a long history; not all of it pretty. Industrial factories once…

Read more »
Capt. Tucker and Hercules. Photo: Kathleen Walls

Cajun Culture in Lafayette Parish

In Southern Louisiana, French Canadian migrants settled and intermingled with the existing community to create a unique ethnic group, the Cajuns, whose culture continues to thrive today. Visitors can learn more about the Cajuns through a visit to Lafay…

Read more »
View of Lake Chelan. Photo: Eliza Amon

No Roads Lead to Stehekin

Tucked in the rugged North Cascade Mountains near the Canadian border, is a town unreachable except by ferry, foot or flight. Remote as Stehekin is, the Washington town is a hub for nature lovers looking to hike, kayak, ride horses or fish in a nationa…

Read more »
Exterior of the Royal Bathouse in Tbilsi. Photo: Sarah May Grunwald

Visiting Tbilisi’s Natural Baths

The Georgian capital Tbilisi’s name derives from a word that means warm place. The word applies to both the glorious sulfur baths on which the city was founded, as well as the generosity and warmth of the Georgian people.  A trip to the baths allows vi…

Read more »

Visiting Panama’s Embera People

Our wooden longboat plied the Chagres River deeper and deeper into the Panamanian rain forest. Soon the boatmen, one wearing a loincloth and the other a beaded skirt, were poling us through channels so narrow that it looked like the river had disappear…

Read more »
uzbekistan-bike.jpg

Cycling in Uzbekistan

In many ways Uzbekistan is a fantastic country to cycle through – the friendly hospitality, exotic culture, stunning architecture and, of course, the excitement of exploring faraway lands, well away from the beaten tourist trail. Tashkent Mosque. Uzbek…

Read more »
Burundi village

A Burundian Lesson in Hospitality

It’s evening in the small African nation of Burundi, and the waning sun throws shadows over the city of Bujumbura. In the old Land Rover, we bump and jostle our way through the crowded dirt roads of the capital. Before we left the mission station where…

Read more »
Statue honoring the underground railroad along the Riverwalk in Detroit.

Heartbeat of Detroit

I didn’t know a single thing about Detroit when I moved here a year ago. Most people plan where they want to move but when your spouse is in medical school, you don’t always have the luxury of choice or time. The sudden relocation to the city was a sur…

Read more »

Three Stops on the Trail of Tears

The rich culture and heritage of the Cherokee people and the story of their forced removal from their homeland is sometimes lost amid undifferentiated accounts of indigenous people in the United States. Three stops along the Georgia section of the Trai…

Read more »
Amazon River at night

Adventures on the Amazon

I stepped back into the dark brown muck and leaned on the tree behind me to get a better photo of the anaconda slithering in my direction. I was motionless for a mere two seconds when Ericson Pinedo, our local naturalist, jerked me back by my arm and q…

Read more »

Eau Claire’s Artistic Wonders

The American heartland city of Eau Claire is enjoying an artistic renaissance. Sitting at the junction of the Eau Claire and Chippewa Rivers in Wisconsin, Eau Claire is French for “clear water,” and water is a defining physical feature of the city. Its…

Read more »

Greece By Sea

“Ferries are for wimps,” our guide Tim’s t-shirt read. It was a motto befitting my tour groups’ plan to spend a week swimming 5km a day between and alongside the Sporades, a cluster of Greek islands in the Aegean Sea. I’d traveled to Greece with four f…

Read more »
Arch leading into Tehran

Discovering Iran by bicycle

I’ve travelled almost 20,000km by bicycle through over 15 countries. Often one of the first questions I’m asked when people discover this is, “What’s been your favourite country to cycle through?” Without hesitation I always answer, “Iran.” Photo:  Hav…

Read more »
Voralberg, Austria

The Tastes of Vorarlberg

In August 2015, I left Canada for greener pastures, departing on a ten month exchange year to Austria. My year spent abroad was unique in many ways, I lived with a host family, attended Austrian school, learned German and explored my surroundings. One…

Read more »
hong-kong-skyline.jpg

Visiting Hong Kong on a budget

Hong Kong is a world famous travel destination that caters mostly to urban adventurers. Although a holiday in Hong Kong can be costly, there are a few inexpensive options you can enjoy without breaking the bank. Hong Kong is an important economic and t…

Read more »